Scorecard Research Beacon
Search Icon
Food February 14, 2018

We tried out 2 popular baking kits: SoBakeable and FoodStirs

WATCH: We tried out 2 popular baking kits: SoBakeable and FoodStirs

Baking kits are becoming a sweet new trend.

You supply the perishables like eggs, milk and butter, and they send you the rest of the ingredients to make things like cookies, cupcakes and even rainbow pancakes.

Food freebies and deals to share with that special someone, or yourself, on Valentine's Day 'The One': Couple's concert engagement goes viral: 'It was too loud for me to say ... will you marry me?'

“We’re all looking for ways to simplify our lives. You know drive-throughs, one-stop stores. And these are sort of in that same vein,” Jo Saltz, editorial director of Delish.com, told “Good Morning America."

“GMA” checked out two baking kits: SoBakeable and Foodstirs. The kits cost $15 each and up, depending on how many you buy.

They can be ordered online to be delivered to your door, either as a single order or via subscription.

SoBakeable “is a little more high end and chic” of the bake kits, according to Saltz.

Foodstirs, co-founded by actress Sarah Michelle Gellar, says it uses organic, non-genetically modified ingredients sourced from small farms, and is more kid-oriented.

Families try out the kits

"GMA" arranged for different people to receive a kit from SoBakeable and Foodstirs and bake the sweets in their homes.

PHOTO:Ingredients for SoBakeable's Chocolate thumbprint cookies come individually packaged.
Sandra Temko/ABC
Ingredients for SoBakeable's Chocolate thumbprint cookies come individually packaged.
PHOTO: SoBakeable's Chocolate thumbprint cookies made by Dana Grant are photographed here.
Sandra Temko/ABC
SoBakeable's Chocolate thumbprint cookies made by Dana Grant are photographed here.

Dana Grant of New York City tried SoBakeable’s chocolate thumbprint cookies, which her husband thought were delicious.

Lara Bursor of New York City and her three daughters made the rainbow cake pop kit from Foodstirs.

PHOTO: The Rainbow Cake Pop kit from Foodstir is shown here.
Sandra Temko/ABC
The Rainbow Cake Pop kit from Foodstir is shown here.
PHOTO: Ingredients are shown for the Rainbow Cake Pop kit from Foodstirs.
Sandra Temko/ABC
Ingredients are shown for the Rainbow Cake Pop kit from Foodstirs.

“It was a fun activity,” Bursor said, “like a big arts and crafts project that was also then edible at the end of the day.”

PHOTO: Lara Bursor and her daughters try the Rainbow Cake Pop kit from Foodstirs.
Sandra Temko/ABC
Lara Bursor and her daughters try the Rainbow Cake Pop kit from Foodstirs.

Vanilla cupcake comparison

“GMA” had Saltz make vanilla cupcakes with vanilla frosting from both companies, without the extra toppings that came with each kit, along with homemade ones.

She said all the cupcakes turned out delicious and good in their own way. The Foodstirs cake was like a dense pound cake, it's made with yogurt, but her favorite overall was SoBakeable's.

PHOTO: SoBakeable's vanilla cupcakes are photographed here.
Sandra Temko/ABC
SoBakeable's vanilla cupcakes are photographed here.

When it came to price, the homemade cupcakes are much less expensive, but the bake kits do come with some extras.

PHOTO: Foodstirs' vanilla cupcakes are photographed here.
Sandra Temko/ABC
Foodstirs' vanilla cupcakes are photographed here.

SoBakeable’s has sprinkles and metallic cupcake liners. Foodstirs has vegan marshmallows and dye-free yellow sugar.

Customers are paying for special items like those, for shipping and for convenience, Saltz noted.