Scorecard Research Beacon
Search Icon
Shop August 2, 2024

The Right Stuff: Discover olive oils that will deliver culinary excellence

WATCH: 'The Right Stuff' spotlights top picks for olive oil

Choosing the right olive oil can elevate any dish, enhancing flavors and bringing a flair to your kitchen.

With countless brands to choose from and a variety of different offerings within each, finding the best of the best can be a daunting task.

To help select some top contenders, "Good Morning America" lifestyle contributor Lori Bergamotto and the "GMA" staff tried and tested to determine which products stood out.

From our favorite flavor to the overall staff pick, scroll on to shop our selections that will solve your culinary conundrum.

By clicking on these shopping links, visitors will leave Goodmorningamerica.com. These e-commerce sites are operated under different terms and privacy policies than Goodmorningamerica.com. ABC will receive a commission for purchases made through these links. Influencers may receive a commission or have business relationships with a recommended brand. SOME PRICES ARE DYNAMIC AND MAY CHANGE FROM THE DATE OF PUBLICATION. Have questions about ordering or a purchase? Click here.

Staff favorite

After testing, "GMA" staff picked the NO.1 & NO.2 oil from Branche as the overall best pick. The brand uses small batch production and cold-presses its oils to ensure the utmost quality.

Branche No. 1 and No. 2 Extra Virgin Olive Oil + Use code ENJOYBRANCHE1 to save 15%

Price: $77 · From Branche

Use code ENJOYBRANCHE1 to save 15%. Limit 1 use of code per customer. Valid until 7 a.m. Eastern Time on Saturday, August 3.

Favorite flavor

According to the Brightland website, "Awake olive oil is a robust cold-pressed extra virgin oil that is best used for roasting, sauteing, soups, stews, bread and more."

Brightland Awake + Use code GMA20 to save 20%

Price: $37 · From Brightland

Use code GMA20 to save 20%. Valid until 7 a.m. Eastern Time on Saturday, August 3.

Iconic duo

Graza is both high-quality and affordable, which means there is zero guilt when using Drizzle and Sizzle on or in absolutely everything. Plus, the squeeze bottles are super fun and easy-to-use and will make you feel like a chef at home.

"The Duo" Drizzle & Sizzle Set

Price: $37 · From Graza

Deluxe pick

Our deluxe pick is from Wonder Valley. According to the brand, "Wonder Valley olive oil has a high concentration of polyphenols (the free-radical fighting antioxidant), which, aside from its potent health benefits, also gives the oil a longer shelf life."

Wonder Valley Olive Oil + Use code GMAWV10 to save 10%

Price: $38 · From Wonder Valley

Use code GMAWV10 to save 10% site wide at WelcomeToWonderValley.com. Not valid on pre-discounted bundles or oil subscriptions. Limit 1 use of code per customer. Valid until 11:59 p.m. Eastern Time on Sunday, August 4.

Value pick

This versatile value pick is great for everyday olive oil when cooking and finishing dishes.

Amazon Fresh, Mediterranean Blend Extra Virgin Olive Oil, 68 Fl Oz

Price: $22.49 · From Amazon

For the baker

If you are looking for an oil to enhance your baking experience, the selection below from Elia is where to look.

Vanilla Bean & Lemon Olive Oil Cake Mix by ELI

Price: $30.59 · 10% Savings
From Amazon

Original: $33.99

Chocolate with a hint of Espresso Organic Cake Mix by ELIA

Price: $30.59 · 10% Savings
From Amazon

Original: $33.99

Almond & Orange Olive Oil Cake Mix by ELIA

Price: $30.59 · 10% Savings
From Amazon

Original: $33.99

Organic extra-virgin olive oil

Public Goods Organic Extra Virgin Olive Oil is perfect for both cooking and drizzling. This oil is incredibly smooth so you can pour over roasted veggies or your favorite salad. This is an essential for your kitchen lineup!

Organic Extra Virgin Olive Oil

Price: $21.95 · From Public Goods

Pizza oil

Pizza alone is the best but what if you can add a little extra flavor? Brightland Pizza Oil has the solution. This hot and herbaceous oil will spice up your pizza game. Not only can you use it for pizza but also goes great with eggs, toast, and even pasta!

Pizza Oil

Price: $28 · From Brightland

Pompeian extra-virgin olive oil

Are you looking for a staple cooking oil in your kitchen? Pompeian Extra Virgin Olive Oil will have to be added to your grocery list. This oil is made from first cold pressed olives. The mild and delicate flavor is perfect for sauteing and stir-frying.

Pompeian Smooth Extra Virgin Olive Oil

Price: $8.23 · From Amazon

More GMA picks to shop

16oz Oil Dispenser Bottle for Kitchen

Price: $8.77 · 12% Savings
From Amazon

Original: $9.99

Olive Oil and Balsamic Vinegar Dipping Platter

Price: $49.99 · From Amazon

Olive Oil Dispenser Bottle Stoneware Ceramic for EVOO or Vinegar

Price: $19.95 · 33% Savings
From Amazon

Original: $29.95

The Olive Oil Enthusiast: A Guide from Tree to Table

Price: $18.91 · 5% Savings
From Amazon

Original: $19.99

Olive Oil Dispenser For Kitchen & Olive Oil Sprayer For Cooking

Price: $29.99 · 17% Savings
From Amazon

Original: $36.49